Finding the Tools That Work for You
Finding what works for you is a crucial part of solo RPGs. The amount of tools available is overwhelming: oracles, generators, tables, GMEs, scenarios, campaigns, and a plethora of supplements to create adventures and develop stories. It's tempting to at least give it a shot to them.
Sometimes, something that should be perfect for you just doesn't click, and it sucks.
I recently bought The Adventure Crafter (TAC). It provides plenty of structure and inspiration for developing plots and creating an adventure from scratch, taking it in unexpected directions.
On paper, it seemed like exactly the kind of thing I'd enjoy. In practice, I struggled to get into it.
It took me a long time to accept that it just wasn't for me. I kept trying to make it work, but it made me procrastinate A LOT. What should be my hobby, my chosen form of happy escapism, became a chore.
I usually try to convince myself that a certain tool should work for me because it worked for some people I follow and admire, and they do wonderful things with it.
I thought I just needed to get more familiar with the system, or find the right way to incorporate it into my style.
And sure, I still think that I might have messed up and could have tried a little more. But I gave up. I've made my peace with that it's just not for me.
Part of my reluctance to let go was definitely the sunk cost fallacy. I'd already spent money on the book, read through it, and invested time trying to use it. Abandoning it felt like such a waste, so I kept insisting.
But like gambling more to recover losses, that doesn't work.
As to why TAC specifically didn't work for me, I'm finding that I love to improvise (to a degree). It's great to have a little direction, but I love filling in the blanks and going off-course.
TAC kind of set me on rails too much for me to enjoy it. The prompts are too specific, and I feel like it limits me more than guide or inspire.
I think there's a tendency to assume that a more complex toolkit will produce better results. It makes sense, right? More prompts, tables, and structure will generate more possibilities and surprises.
In this case, I'm finding that less is more. Introducing more friction didn't pay off accordingly.
I love crunch, procedures, details, etc, but apparently there's a limit to it. Who knew.
I'm glad I gave TAC a shot because it helped me better understand what I want from my solo games and supplements.
I'm also finding that I love the idea of playing analog, writing things down on a notebook, but I'm more and more tending to digital.
Discovering what works means experimenting. That's how we find our tastes and build our toolbox, so trying the wrong tools is awesome because it helps us find the right ones.